Have we found an answer to the question yet?  Rebecca Black - So Bad She's Good or Just Plain Terrible? If you listen to the critics, she's just plain terrible.  The song has been called "horribly dreadful", "inept", "overly simple and repetitive", and Black is a "YouTube laughing stock."  However, there have been some positive reviews... kinda.  Joseph Lynch from Entertainment Weekly said,

"something sickeningly catchy about this tune that keeps you coming back for more".

Chris Brown (Yes, CHRIS BROWN) said,

"Honest opinion? It was great. I'll be jammin' to it on Friday, Friday"

Rebecca has expressed interest in working with Justin Bieber and would like to silence the critics who believe she can only sing with the use of Auto Tune.  To do that, she's recording an acoustic version of "Friday".   And the icing on the cake, just like "Bieber Fever", fans have already come up with their own sickness for Rebecca Black... "The Black Plague"